News Literacy GuideBook

Success With News Literacy

Lesson 1. Success With News Literacy (The Standard)
What News Literacy Means

News literacy is the skill of getting an accurate picture of current events from the news while filtering out reports that are biased, false, or misleading.

Examples of News Literacy
  • A parent sees a viral post claiming a childhood vaccine causes autism, finds that reliable health reporting shows no such link, and keeps their child’s shots on schedule.
  • A retiree reads an article promising 20% returns from a new crypto fund, finds that reliable financial news calls it a likely scam, and keeps their savings.
  • Before a local election, a voter sets aside a mailer’s claims about a ballot measure, reads what quality outlets say it would do, and votes knowing its real effect.
  • A worker about to share a shocking quote from a senator checks it first, finds it was made up, and doesn’t pass it on.
  • During a hurricane, a family ignores rumors in a neighborhood chat, follows the weather service and local news, and evacuates on time.
  • A commuter drops a feed that left them angry every morning, switches to a short daily read of a few quality sources, and is better informed with less stress.

In each example, a person got an accurate picture of current events and filtered out a report that was biased, false, or misleading.

Standard for News Literacy
  1. Explain news literacy well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Follow the news and reliably get four results:
    • Coverage: you know the important things happening in the world around you.
    • Accuracy: what you believe from the news is likely to be true, and biased, false, or misleading reports don’t fool you.
    • Composure: you respond to the news with feelings that fit the facts and help you act.
    • Ease: you stay informed with little wasted time or effort.
Lesson 2. Why News Literacy Matters (Rationale)
Reasons for News Literacy
  • Less time, less stress
    • A few good sources and a quick check replace endless scrolling and doom-reading, so you feel calmer and get your time back.
  • Better decisions
    • You act on what’s actually true about health, money, safety, and voting, not on a scary headline or a sales pitch dressed up as news.
  • Not fooled
    • You catch false and misleading claims, whether they come from bad actors or from well-meaning people who believed them.
  • An accurate picture of the world
    • You know what’s really happening and how big it is, not a picture warped by outrage, fear, or one side’s spin.
  • Protect the people around you
    • False claims stop with you instead of spreading, and you can help family and friends steer clear of scams and health scares.
  • Trusted by others
    • Friends and family learn that what you pass on holds up.
Costs and Tradeoffs
  • Time: checking a claim that matters takes a minute or two, and more for big decisions.
  • Learning it: the basics take a few hours. Judging sources and evidence well takes months of practice.
  • Discomfort: sometimes the evidence goes against what you or your group believe.
  • Social friction: questioning a claim a friend shared can feel awkward.
  • Money: some of the best sources are behind paywalls.
When It Matters
  • When a claim would change what you do: a health choice, an investment, a purchase, a vote.
  • When a story is emotionally charged or spreading fast.
  • Before you share something.
  • It matters less for low-stakes news you won’t act on, where a quick skim is enough.
Who It Matters Most To
  • Anyone who makes decisions for others: parents, caregivers, voters, managers, teachers.
  • Heavy social-media users, since false claims spread fastest in feeds.
  • It matters less to people who rarely follow news, though claims still reach them through friends and ads.
Lesson 3. Causes of Success (Causal Model)

Success with news literacy means staying well informed: knowing the important things happening around you, believing what is likely true, reacting with feelings that fit the facts, and spending little time or effort to do it. This success is caused by the following three essential causes:

Good sources

Getting most of your news from a few sources that meet a quality standard for news.

Cross-checking

Comparing what independent good sources report about the claims that matter to you.

Evaluation

Judging the claims that matter against the evidence and the right standard, with effort matched to the stakes.

The next lesson turns these causes into a recipe you can follow.

Lesson 4. Recipe for Success (Process)

Success with news literacy comes from good sources, cross-checking, and evaluation. Here is a recipe that puts all three to work on the news that reaches you each day.

  1. Good sources: Get most of your news from a few sources that meet a quality standard for news.
  2. Claims that matter: From your sources and anything else that reaches you, such as a post, an ad, or a friend, pick the few claims that would change what you believe, do, or share.
  3. Cross-checking: Compare what other good sources, independent of the first, report about each of those claims.
  4. Evaluation: Judge each claim against the evidence and the right standard, and decide how sure to be.
  5. Response: Act on or share only what holds up, respond with feelings that fit the facts, and stop once your answer is good enough for the stakes.
Lesson 5. Learning the Recipe (The Try-Improve Loop)
The Try-Improve Loop

Nobody becomes news literate by reading about it. You get good by running the recipe many times and improving each time.

  1. Try: Run the recipe on a day’s news, or on one claim that reaches you.
  2. Look back: When more facts come in, compare what you believed with what turned out to be true, and find the step that let you down.
  3. Improve: Work on that one step, then run the recipe again.

Repeat the loop until you reliably meet the standard.

Tasks With Feedback

A TwF (task with feedback) is a task you attempt, paired with feedback that compares your attempt with a standard.

  • TwFs are how you run the loop: you check a story or a claim, find your gaps, close them, and repeat until you reliably meet the standard.
  • They show whether you’ve learned: you meet the standard when you can pass the Mastery TwFs on your own, months after you stop practicing.
  • They keep you from fooling yourself. Reading about news literacy makes it feel easy; a TwF shows whether you can do it.
  • They save time. You work on your gaps, not on what you already know.

TwFs come in four levels, from a first try to the full standard: Basics, Apply, Range, and Mastery.

The rest of this GuideBook teaches you how to run the recipe.

Key Ideas

Orientation
What Key Ideas of News Literacy Mean

The key ideas of news literacy are the ideas a person needs in order to start running the recipe.

Standard for This Part
  1. Explain each key idea well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Use the key ideas to run the recipe on a simple case, such as checking a news report that a food you buy has been recalled, well enough to meet the standard for news literacy.
Why This Part Matters

This part supplies the few ideas that each step of the recipe needs on a simple case, such as a report that a food you buy has been recalled. With them, you can run the whole recipe on your first real news story and start the Try-Improve Loop toward the standard for news literacy. They also give you plain words for saying why you trust a report, or why you don’t.

Meeting the Standard (How To)
Recipe
  1. A simple case: Choose a short news report you could act on, such as a recall of a food you buy.
  2. Good sources: Ask whether the report comes from a good source, one that meets the News Standard.
  3. Claims that matter: Pick out its main claim, and judge its stakes for you.
  4. Cross-checking: See whether independent sources report the same claim.
  5. Evaluation: Weigh the evidence, and set your confidence to match.
  6. Response: Act if the claim holds up, such as by checking your kitchen for the food.
Key Ideas
  • Claim: a statement that asserts that something is or is not the case
  • Standard: a description of what is most desirable for something
  • News Standard: reporting that is accurate and fair, with any opinion labeled and well grounded
  • Good source: a source that meets the News Standard most of the time
  • Stakes: what you could gain or lose depending on whether you get a claim right
  • Independent sources: sources whose reports don’t trace back to the same origin
  • Evidence: information that makes a claim more or less likely to be true
  • Confidence: how sure you are that a claim is true
Lesson 6. Claim
What a Claim Means

A claim is a statement that asserts that something is or is not the case.

Why This Matters

Claims are what the news asks you to believe, so spotting them tells you what to check.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain what a claim is well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Pick out the main claims in a news story, a post, or an ad.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Statements: Find the sentences that state something as so.
  2. Main claims: Pick the ones the story rests on, or that would change what you believe or do.
  3. Plain wording: Restate each in one plain sentence that could be checked.
Key Ideas
  • Main claim: a claim a story or post is built to get across
  • Question: asks rather than asserts, so it isn’t a claim
  • Topic: what a story is about, not something it asserts
Lesson 7. Standard
What a Standard Means

A standard for X is a description of what is most desirable for X.

Why This Matters

A standard turns “good” from a feeling into something you can check, so your judgments are clear and fair.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain what a standard is well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Use a standard to judge whether something is good enough, such as tap water, a used car, or a movie.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Purpose: Name what the thing is for.
  2. Criteria: List what the most desirable version looks like.
  3. Comparison: Compare the thing with each criterion.
  4. Verdict: Say whether it is good enough, and why.
Key Ideas
  • Criterion: one thing a standard checks
  • Good enough: meeting the standard well enough for your purpose
Lesson 8. News Standard
What the News Standard Means

The News Standard is the standard for news: reporting that is accurate and fair, with any opinion labeled and well grounded.

Why This Matters

The News Standard tells you what good reporting looks like, so you can judge any report instead of trusting it by feel.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain the News Standard well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Judge whether a news report, such as a story on a new law or a health study, meets the News Standard.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Accuracy: Check that its facts are correct and that it says where they came from.
  2. Fairness: Check that it gives the relevant sides and the context.
  3. Opinion: Check that any opinion is labeled and well grounded.
  4. Verdict: Decide whether the report meets the standard.
Key Ideas
  • Standard: a description of what is most desirable for something
  • Accurate: facts that are correct and traced to their sources
  • Fair: relevant sides and context given, with no thumb on the scale
  • Opinion: content that argues for a view rather than reporting what happened
Lesson 9. Good Source
What a Good Source Means

A good source of news is one that meets the News Standard most of the time.

Why This Matters

Most of what you believe about the world comes from your sources, so good ones give you an accurate picture for little effort.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain what a good source is well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Judge whether a news source you use, or the source behind a post you see, is a good source.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Track record: Ask how often the source meets the News Standard.
  2. Signs: Look for the signs of a good source.
  3. Outside view: See what other good sources say about it.
  4. Verdict: Decide whether to rely on it.
Key Ideas
  • News Standard: reporting that is accurate and fair, with any opinion labeled and well grounded
  • Signs of a good source: practices you can see that show a source works to meet the News Standard
  • Popular source: one many people use, which may or may not meet the News Standard
Lesson 10. Stakes
What Stakes Mean

The stakes of a claim are what you could gain or lose depending on whether you get it right.

Why This Matters

The stakes tell you which claims deserve your time, so you check what matters and skip what doesn’t.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain stakes well enough that others can learn to apply them.
  2. Judge the stakes of the claims that reach you, such as a health warning or a celebrity rumor, and match your checking to them.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Effect: Ask what you would do differently if the claim were true.
  2. Cost of error: Ask what you would lose by getting it wrong.
  3. Effort: Match how much you check to what’s at stake.
Key Ideas
  • High stakes: claims that touch your health, money, safety, vote, or what you share
  • Low stakes: news you won’t act on
Lesson 11. Independent Sources
What Independent Sources Mean

Sources are independent when their reports on a claim don’t trace back to the same origin.

Why This Matters

Only independent sources give you a real second opinion; many outlets repeating one report count as one.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain independent sources well enough that others can learn to apply them.
  2. Tell whether the sources reporting a claim, such as a quote or a crime statistic, are independent of each other.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Attribution: Find where each source says it got the claim.
  2. Trace: See whether those trails lead back to the same report.
  3. Count: Count only the sources that reached the claim on their own.
Key Ideas
  • Origin: the first report or person that made a claim
  • Echo: an outlet repeating another outlet’s report
Lesson 12. Evidence
What Evidence Means

Evidence is information that makes a claim more or less likely to be true.

Why This Matters

Evidence is what lets you tell a true claim from one that is only repeated or asserted.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain evidence well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Find the evidence behind a claim in the news, and judge how strongly it supports the claim.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Search: Look for what the claim rests on, such as data, documents, or eyewitnesses.
  2. Relevance: Check that it bears on the claim.
  3. Strength: Judge how strongly it supports or undercuts the claim.
Key Ideas
  • Assertion: saying a claim is true, with nothing to back it
  • Evidence against: information that makes a claim less likely
  • Strength of evidence: how much a piece of evidence moves the likelihood
Lesson 13. Confidence
What Confidence Means

Confidence is how sure you are that a claim is true.

Why This Matters

Matching your confidence to the evidence keeps you from being too sure of a wrong report or too doubtful of a solid one.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain confidence well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Hold the claims in the news with the confidence their evidence supports, such as the first reports of a disaster.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Evidence: Look at how strong the evidence is.
  2. Level: Choose how sure to be, from doubtful to nearly certain.
  3. Updating: Change your confidence as new evidence comes in.
Key Ideas
  • Certainty: being completely sure, which the news rarely warrants
  • Calibration: confidence that matches the evidence

Choosing Good Sources

Orientation
What Choosing Good Sources Means

Choosing good sources is selecting the few news sources you rely on by how often they meet the News Standard.

Standard for This Part
  1. Explain how to choose good sources well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Choose a small set of news sources that meet the News Standard, and judge any new source that reaches you, such as the site behind a viral post.
Why This Part Matters

This part takes the Good sources step of the recipe deeper. You can’t check everything, so your sources decide most of what you believe about the world. Choosing them well gives you the coverage and accuracy the standard for news literacy asks for, for little effort, and frees you from sources that waste your time or steer you.

Meeting the Standard (How To)
Recipe
  1. Candidates: Find possible sources through source ratings and the sources you already use (see Source Rating).
  2. Outside view: Read laterally to see what others say about each one (see Lateral Reading).
  3. Signs: Check each for the signs of a good source, such as labeled opinion and published corrections (see Signs of a Good Source and Opinion).
  4. Spot-check: Judge a few of its recent reports against the News Standard, watching for bias (see Spot-Checking a Source and Bias).
  5. Source list: Keep the few that pass, covering the news you need, and revise the list as you learn (see Source List).
Key Ideas
  • News Standard: reporting that is accurate and fair, with any opinion labeled and well grounded
  • Good source: a source that meets the News Standard most of the time
  • Opinion: content that argues for a view rather than reporting what happened
  • Bias: a consistent pattern of departing from a standard in one direction
Lesson 14. Opinion
What Opinion Means

Opinion, in the news, is content that argues for a view rather than reporting what happened.

Why This Matters

Telling opinion from reporting keeps you from taking an argument as a report of the facts.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain opinion well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Tell opinion from reporting in a news source, even when it isn’t labeled.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Label: Look for labels such as Opinion, Editorial, or Commentary.
  2. Language: Watch for words that judge or urge.
  3. Purpose: Ask whether it tells what happened or argues for a view.
Key Ideas
  • Reporting: content that tells what happened
  • Analysis: reporting that explains what events mean, labeled as such
  • Value claim: a claim that something is good or bad, or that something should be done
Lesson 15. Bias
What Bias Means

Bias is a consistent pattern of departing from a standard in one direction.

Why This Matters

Spotting bias shows you which way a source, or you, lean, so you can correct for it.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain bias well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Spot bias in a news source’s coverage, and in how you yourself react to the news.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Pattern: Look across many reports, not one.
  2. Direction: Ask whether the departures from the News Standard lean one way.
  3. Self-check: Ask whether your own reactions lean the same way.
Key Ideas
  • One-off mistake: an error with no pattern behind it
  • Slant: bias in what a source covers or how it covers it
  • Motivated reasoning: judging a claim by what you want to be true
Lesson 16. Signs of a Good Source
What the Signs of a Good Source Mean

The signs of a good source are practices you can see that show it works to meet the News Standard.

Why This Matters

The signs let you judge a source quickly from what you can see, before you know its track record.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain the signs of a good source well enough that others can learn to apply them.
  2. Check a news source, such as one you use or one behind a viral post, for the signs of a good source.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Corrections: Look for a corrections policy and published corrections.
  2. Sourcing: Check that it names its sources.
  3. Labels: Check that opinion is labeled.
  4. Accountability: Look for named authors and a page saying who runs it.
Key Ideas
  • Polish: a professional look, which anyone can buy
  • Opinion: content that argues for a view rather than reporting what happened
Lesson 17. Lateral Reading
What Lateral Reading Means

Lateral reading is judging a source or claim by leaving it and seeing what other sources say about it.

Why This Matters

Lateral reading tells you about an unfamiliar source in minutes, where reading the site itself can mislead you.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain lateral reading well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Use lateral reading to judge an unfamiliar source quickly, such as a site you’ve never heard of.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Exit: Open a new tab instead of reading the site closely.
  2. Search: Search for the source’s name, or for the claim.
  3. Comparison: See what good sources say about it.
  4. Verdict: Decide whether to trust it.
Key Ideas
  • Vertical reading: judging a site from the site itself
  • Good source: a source that meets the News Standard most of the time
Lesson 18. Source Rating
What a Source Rating Means

A source rating is an independent group’s judgment of how well a news source meets a standard for news.

Why This Matters

Source ratings let you draw on others’ careful work to find good sources and screen new ones fast.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain what a source rating is well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Use a source rating, such as Ad Fontes Media’s, to find candidate good sources and to screen a new one.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Rater: Pick an independent rater, such as Ad Fontes Media.
  2. Lookup: Find the source’s ratings for reliability and bias.
  3. Use: Treat the rating as a strong hint, then confirm it with a spot-check.
Key Ideas
  • Reliability rating: how well a source meets a standard for news
  • Bias rating: which way a source leans, and how far
  • Spot-checking a source: judging a few of its recent reports yourself
Lesson 19. Spot-Checking a Source
What Spot-Checking a Source Means

Spot-checking a source is judging a few of its recent reports against the News Standard.

Why This Matters

Spot-checking shows you whether a source meets the News Standard in practice, not just by reputation.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain spot-checking a source well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Spot-check a news source you use or are thinking of using, and decide whether to keep it.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Sample: Pick a few recent reports, including some on topics you know well.
  2. Check: Judge each against the News Standard.
  3. Verdict: Keep the source, drop it, or watch it.
Key Ideas
  • News Standard: reporting that is accurate and fair, with any opinion labeled and well grounded
  • Known topic: a subject you know well, where errors are easy to spot
Lesson 20. Source List
What a Source List Means

A source list is the small set of good sources you rely on for most of your news.

Why This Matters

A short source list gives you reliable coverage of the news you need with little time or effort.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain what a source list is well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Build a source list that covers the news you need, such as world, local, and topics you care about, and revise it as you learn.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Needs: Name the news you need, such as world, local, and topics you care about.
  2. Picks: Choose a good source or two for each.
  3. Review: Revise the list as you spot-check and learn.
Key Ideas
  • Good source: a source that meets the News Standard most of the time
  • Spot-checking a source: judging a few of its recent reports against the News Standard
  • Coverage: knowing the important things happening in your world

Checking a Claim

Orientation
What Checking a Claim Means

Checking a claim is picking out a claim in the news that matters to you and comparing what independent good sources report about it.

Standard for This Part
  1. Explain checking a claim well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Check the claims that matter in the news that reaches you, such as a shocking quote or a health warning, so you know where good sources agree, where they differ, and what is still unknown.
Why This Part Matters

This part takes the Claims that matter and Cross-checking steps of the recipe deeper. Even good sources sometimes get a story wrong, and claims that reach you through posts and friends have had no quality check at all. Checking the few claims that matter keeps one bad report from steering what you believe, do, or share, which is the accuracy the standard for news literacy asks for.

Meeting the Standard (How To)
Recipe
  1. Picking: Choose the few claims whose stakes call for checking (see Picking the Claims That Matter).
  2. Origin: Trace each one back to the first report or person that made it (see Origin of a Claim).
  3. Cross-checking: Compare what independent good sources report about it (see Cross-Checking).
  4. Fact-checks: Add what fact-checkers have found, as one more independent source (see Fact-Checker).
  5. Summary: Say where good sources agree, where they differ, and what is still unknown.
Key Ideas
  • Claim: a statement that asserts that something is or is not the case
  • Stakes: what you could gain or lose depending on whether you get a claim right
  • Good source: a source that meets the News Standard most of the time
  • Independent sources: sources whose reports don’t trace back to the same origin
Lesson 21. Picking the Claims That Matter
What Picking the Claims That Matter Means

Picking the claims that matter is choosing, from all the claims that reach you, the few whose stakes call for checking.

Why This Matters

Picking the few claims that matter lets you check what counts without wearing yourself out.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain picking the claims that matter well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Pick the claims worth checking from a day’s news and your feeds.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Scan: Note the main claims in a day’s news and your feeds.
  2. Stakes: Judge what each would change for you or the people you’d share it with.
  3. Choice: Pick the few whose stakes call for checking, and let the rest go.
Key Ideas
  • Claim: a statement that asserts that something is or is not the case
  • Stakes: what you could gain or lose depending on whether you get a claim right
Lesson 22. Origin of a Claim
What the Origin of a Claim Means

The origin of a claim is the first report or person that made it.

Why This Matters

Finding the origin shows what a claim really rests on, and whether it changed as it spread.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain the origin of a claim well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Trace a claim, such as a viral quote or a shocking statistic, back to its origin.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Links: Follow links and citations back toward the source.
  2. Search: Search for key words or the exact quote to find the first report.
  3. Comparison: Compare the origin with the version that reached you.
Key Ideas
  • Primary source: the original document, data, or person
  • Drift: a change in a claim as it passes from one teller to the next
  • Independent sources: sources whose reports don’t trace back to the same origin
Lesson 23. Cross-Checking
What Cross-Checking Means

Cross-checking is comparing what independent good sources report about the same claim.

Why This Matters

Cross-checking catches the errors any one source can make, so one bad report doesn’t fool you.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain cross-checking well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Cross-check a claim that matters, and say where good sources agree, where they differ, and what is still unknown.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Sources: Find other good sources, independent of the first.
  2. Comparison: Compare what each reports about the claim.
  3. Summary: Note where they agree, where they differ, and what is still unknown.
Key Ideas
  • Independent sources: sources whose reports don’t trace back to the same origin
  • Good source: a source that meets the News Standard most of the time
  • Confirmation search: searching until you find a source that agrees with you
Lesson 24. Fact-Checker
What a Fact-Checker Means

A fact-checker is an organization that checks specific public claims against evidence and publishes what it finds.

Why This Matters

Fact-checkers have often already checked a viral claim, which saves you time.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain what a fact-checker is well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Use fact-checkers as one of your independent sources when you cross-check a claim, such as a politician’s statement or a viral post.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Search: Search one or two fact-checkers for the claim.
  2. Reasons: Read the verdict and the evidence behind it.
  3. Weight: Count it as one independent source among others.
Key Ideas
  • Rating scale: a fact-checker’s verdict labels, such as True, Mostly False, or Missing Context
  • Independent sources: sources whose reports don’t trace back to the same origin

Evaluating a Claim

Orientation
What Evaluating a Claim Means

Evaluating a claim is judging it against the evidence, for a fact claim, or against the right standard, for a value claim.

Standard for This Part
  1. Explain evaluating a claim well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Evaluate the key claims in a news story, such as a report on crime rates or an argument for a ballot measure, and hold each with the confidence its evidence supports.
Why This Part Matters

This part takes the Evaluation step of the recipe deeper and widens it to value claims. When good sources disagree, or a claim is about what’s good or what should be done, comparing reports isn’t enough. Evaluating a claim yourself lets you decide what to believe, and how sure to be, instead of taking someone’s word for it, so what you believe from the news is likely to be true.

Meeting the Standard (How To)
Recipe
  1. Claim type: Tell whether the claim is a fact claim or a value claim (see Value Claim).
  2. Evidence: For a fact claim, judge how strong the evidence is, reading any statistic or claim of cause with care (see Strength of Evidence, Statistic, and Cause).
  3. Experts: Find what the expert consensus is, if there is one (see Expert Consensus).
  4. Standard: For a value claim, compare it with the right standard and check the facts it rests on (see Judging a Value Claim).
  5. Traps: Check for a misleading report and for your own motivated reasoning (see Misleading Report and Motivated Reasoning).
  6. Confidence: Hold the claim with the confidence its evidence supports.
Key Ideas
  • Evidence: information that makes a claim more or less likely to be true
  • Confidence: how sure you are that a claim is true
  • Standard: a description of what is most desirable for something
  • Opinion: content that argues for a view rather than reporting what happened
  • Bias: a consistent pattern of departing from a standard in one direction
Lesson 25. Strength of Evidence
What the Strength of Evidence Means

The strength of evidence is how much a piece of evidence raises or lowers the likelihood that a claim is true.

Why This Matters

Judging the strength of evidence keeps you from being swayed by a vivid story or a pile of weak reports.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain the strength of evidence well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Judge how strong the evidence is for a claim in the news, such as a study, an eyewitness account, or a single anecdote.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Kind: Note what kind of evidence it is, such as a study, a record, or an anecdote.
  2. Quality: Ask how carefully it was gathered and whether others could check it.
  3. Fit: Ask how directly it bears on the claim.
  4. Weight: Decide how much it raises or lowers the likelihood of the claim.
Key Ideas
  • Anecdote: a single story, weak evidence for a general claim
  • Amount: many weak pieces of evidence can count for less than one strong one
  • Evidence: information that makes a claim more or less likely to be true
Lesson 26. Statistic
What a Statistic Means

A statistic is a number that summarizes data about a group.

Why This Matters

Reading statistics well keeps true numbers from giving you a false picture.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain what a statistic is well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Read a statistic in the news, such as a crime rate, by asking what it counts, compared with what, and over what time.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Count: Ask what exactly it counts.
  2. Comparison: Ask what it is compared with, such as last year or another place.
  3. Period: Ask what span of time it covers.
  4. Source: Ask who gathered the data, and how.
Key Ideas
  • Rate and total: a count per person, and a raw count, which can tell different stories
  • Baseline: what a number is compared with
Lesson 27. Cause
What a Cause Means

A cause is something that brings about a change in something else.

Why This Matters

Telling a cause from a mere link keeps you from acting on studies that don’t show what the headline says.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain what a cause is well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Judge whether a news story’s evidence shows a cause or only a link, such as a study tying coffee to a longer life.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Link: Note what the story says goes with what.
  2. Design: Ask whether the study tested the cause, such as with an experiment.
  3. Other causes: Look for something else that could explain the link.
Key Ideas
  • Correlation: two things that tend to go together, which doesn’t show that one causes the other
  • Experiment: a study that changes one thing on purpose and watches the result
  • Confounder: a third thing that drives both
Lesson 28. Expert Consensus
What Expert Consensus Means

Expert consensus is the shared judgment of most experts in a field on a question in that field.

Why This Matters

Expert consensus is often your best guide on questions you can’t check yourself.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain expert consensus well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Find and use the expert consensus on a claim in the news, such as one about vaccine safety or climate.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Field: Name the field whose experts know the question.
  2. Bodies: Find what the field’s major scientific or professional bodies say.
  3. Fit: Check whether the claim matches the consensus, and how far it departs if not.
Key Ideas
  • Lone expert: one expert’s view, which may differ from the field’s
  • Scientific body: a group, such as a national academy, that sums up a field’s view
Lesson 29. Misleading Report
What a Misleading Report Means

A misleading report is one that leaves a false impression, even when each of its statements is true.

Why This Matters

Spotting misleading reports protects you from claims that are true in each detail but false overall.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain what a misleading report is well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Spot misleading reports in the news, such as a true statistic with its context left out.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Impression: Note what the report leads you to believe.
  2. Context: Look for what’s left out, such as a baseline or the rest of a quote.
  3. Comparison: Check whether the full picture supports the impression.
Key Ideas
  • Cherry-picking: choosing only the facts that fit
  • Missing context: facts left out that would change the impression
  • False report: one with a false statement in it
Lesson 30. Motivated Reasoning
What Motivated Reasoning Means

Motivated reasoning is judging a claim by what you want to be true rather than by the evidence.

Why This Matters

Catching motivated reasoning keeps your wishes from deciding what you believe.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain motivated reasoning well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Catch motivated reasoning in yourself when a story pleases or angers you, and judge the claim on its evidence.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Reaction: Notice when a story pleases or angers you.
  2. Reversal: Ask how you would judge the same evidence if it favored the other side.
  3. Evidence: Judge the claim on its evidence alone.
Key Ideas
  • Confirmation bias: favoring evidence that fits what you already think
  • Bias: a consistent pattern of departing from a standard in one direction
Lesson 31. Value Claim
What a Value Claim Means

A value claim is a claim that something is good or bad, or that something should be done.

Why This Matters

Knowing a value claim from a fact claim tells you whether to check it against a standard or against evidence.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain what a value claim is well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Tell value claims from fact claims in a news story or an editorial, so you know whether to judge each against a standard or against evidence.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Wording: Look for words such as good, bad, best, should, or must.
  2. Test: Ask whether evidence alone could settle the claim.
  3. Label: Call it a value claim or a fact claim.
Key Ideas
  • Fact claim: a claim about what is or was so, checked against evidence
  • Standard: a description of what is most desirable for something
Lesson 32. Judging a Value Claim
What Judging a Value Claim Means

Judging a value claim is comparing it with the right standard and checking the facts it rests on.

Why This Matters

Judging value claims lets you weigh arguments about what should be done instead of picking a side by feel.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain judging a value claim well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Judge a value claim in the news, such as an argument for a ballot measure or an editorial on a new policy.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Standard: Name the standard the claim rests on, even if it goes unstated.
  2. Fit: Ask whether that standard fits the purpose.
  3. Facts: Check the facts the claim rests on.
  4. Verdict: Decide how well the claim holds up.
Key Ideas
  • Value claim: a claim that something is good or bad, or that something should be done
  • Standard: a description of what is most desirable for something
  • Evidence: information that makes a claim more or less likely to be true

Staying Informed

Orientation
What Staying Informed Means

Staying informed is running the recipe as a regular habit on the news that reaches you.

Standard for This Part
  1. Explain staying informed well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Keep an accurate picture of the important events in your world through a news habit that fits your life, respond to the news with feelings that fit the facts and help you act, and waste little time or effort.
Why This Part Matters

This part widens the recipe from one story to the news that reaches you every day, which is where the coverage, composure, and ease in the standard for news literacy come from. News literacy pays off only if you keep it up. You can take in the news the way you take in the weather: learn what’s happening and what to do about it, without the endless scrolling, outrage, and dread that drive many people to give up on the news.

Meeting the Standard (How To)
Recipe
  1. Habit: Set a regular time and use your source list to take in the news (see News Habit).
  2. Feeds: Shape or limit your feeds so they don’t take over (see News Feed).
  3. Framing: Set aside framing meant to stir you up, and look for the facts (see Emotional Framing).
  4. Composure: Respond with feelings that fit the facts: act where you can, and accept what you can’t change (see Composure).
  5. Stopping: Stop checking once your answer is good enough for the stakes, and hold early reports loosely (see Stopping Point and Developing Story).
  6. Sharing: Share only what holds up, and correct what turns out wrong (see Sharing News).
Key Ideas
  • Source list: the small set of good sources you rely on for most of your news
  • Stakes: what you could gain or lose depending on whether you get a claim right
  • Confidence: how sure you are that a claim is true
  • Cross-checking: comparing what independent good sources report about the same claim
Lesson 33. News Habit
What a News Habit Means

A news habit is the routine by which you regularly take in the news.

Why This Matters

A good news habit keeps you informed with little effort and keeps the news from taking over your day.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain what a news habit is well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Set up a news habit that fits your life and covers the news you need.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Time: Choose when, and for how long, you’ll take in the news.
  2. Sources: Go to your source list first.
  3. Review: Adjust the habit when it leaves gaps or takes too much time.
Key Ideas
  • Source list: the small set of good sources you rely on for most of your news
  • Coverage and ease: knowing what matters, with little wasted time or effort
Lesson 34. News Feed
What a News Feed Means

A news feed is a stream of posts and stories that a platform picks for you.

Why This Matters

Shaping your feeds keeps a platform’s choices from deciding what you see and how you feel.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain what a news feed is well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Shape or limit your feeds so they serve your news habit instead of taking it over.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Audit: Notice what your feeds show you and how they leave you feeling.
  2. Pruning: Mute or unfollow accounts that mislead you or stir you up.
  3. Limits: Set times or limits for your feeds.
  4. Priority: Go to your source list before your feeds.
Key Ideas
  • Algorithm: the rules a platform uses to pick what you see
  • Engagement: clicks, shares, and time spent, which platforms aim to raise, often with outrage
  • Source list: the small set of good sources you rely on for most of your news
Lesson 35. Emotional Framing
What Emotional Framing Means

Emotional framing is presenting news in a way meant to stir strong feelings.

Why This Matters

Seeing emotional framing lets you feel what the facts warrant, not what a headline wants you to feel.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain emotional framing well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Spot emotional framing in a story or post, and set it aside to see the facts.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Feeling: Notice the feeling a story stirs in you.
  2. Wording: Find the words or images that stir it.
  3. Facts: Restate the facts in neutral words.
Key Ideas
  • Loaded words: words chosen to stir feeling, such as “slams” or “chaos”
  • Clickbait: a headline built to make you click rather than to inform
Lesson 36. Composure
What Composure Means

Composure is keeping a clear head when events could upset you.

Why This Matters

Composure lets you face bad news, act where you can, and keep your peace.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain composure well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Respond to a distressing story with feelings that fit the facts: act where you can, and accept what you can’t change, as you would bad weather.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Pause: Notice the feeling, and take a breath before you react.
  2. Scale: Ask how big the event is and how it affects you.
  3. Action: Act where you can.
  4. Acceptance: Accept what you can’t change, as you would bad weather.
Key Ideas
  • Not caring: shutting the news out, which isn’t composure
  • Emotional framing: presenting news in a way meant to stir strong feelings
Lesson 37. Stopping Point
What a Stopping Point Means

A stopping point is the moment your answer about a claim is good enough for its stakes.

Why This Matters

Knowing when to stop saves time on small claims and keeps you checking on big ones.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain a stopping point well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Stop checking a claim once your answer is good enough for its stakes, such as a celebrity rumor or a medical decision.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Stakes: Recall what’s at stake with the claim.
  2. Sufficiency: Ask whether your answer is good enough to act on.
  3. Stop: Stop when it is, and note how sure you are.
Key Ideas
  • Stakes: what you could gain or lose depending on whether you get a claim right
  • Confidence: how sure you are that a claim is true
  • Certainty: being completely sure, which you rarely need before you act
Lesson 38. Developing Story
What a Developing Story Means

A developing story is a news story whose facts are still coming in.

Why This Matters

Holding early reports loosely keeps you from believing, and sharing, what later turns out wrong.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain what a developing story is well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Hold early reports on a developing story, such as a shooting or a disaster, loosely, and update as the facts arrive.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Recognition: Notice when the facts are still coming in.
  2. Light hold: Treat early reports as tentative.
  3. Updating: Come back as better reports arrive, and change your view to match.
Key Ideas
  • Early reports: first accounts, often wrong in their details
  • Confidence: how sure you are that a claim is true
Lesson 39. Sharing News
What Sharing News Means

Sharing news is passing a report or claim on to other people.

Why This Matters

Sharing only what holds up protects the people you care about and keeps their trust in you.

Standard for This Lesson
  1. Explain sharing news well enough that others can learn to apply it.
  2. Share only claims that hold up, say how sure you are, and correct what you shared when it turns out wrong.
Meeting the Standard (How To)
Process
  1. Check: Share only claims that hold up.
  2. Confidence: Say how sure you are.
  3. Correction: Correct what you shared when it turns out wrong.
Key Ideas
  • Viral post: content that spreads fast, often before anyone checks it
  • Cross-checking: comparing what independent good sources report about the same claim